Justice Michael Elubu in his sentencing judgement noted that the 40 year’s jail sentence on murder charges properly reflects the overall criminality of Thomas Kwoyelo.
The International Crimes Division
of the High Court (ICD) has sentenced to 40 years in jail former Lord’s
Resistance Army rebel commander Thomas Kwoyelo over war crimes and crimes
against humanity.
The sentence was
delivered Friday by a four-member panel of judges of the ICD sitting at Gulu
High Court in Northern Uganda.
Kwoyelo was convicted in August
this year of 44 crimes relating to murder, torture, rape, pillaging,
kidnapping with intent to murder, cruel treatment, and outrages to personal
dignity. The crimes were committed between March 1993 and June 2005 in Kilak County, in Lamogi and Pabbo Sub-counties in Amuru district.
He will serve 25 years of the 40
years’ jail sentence after the deduction of 15 years, the period he spent in
custody at Luzira Maximum Prison since his incarceration in 2009.
Justice Michael Elubu in his sentencing judgement
noted that the 40-year jail sentence on murder charges properly reflects the
overall criminality of Thomas Kwoyelo.
Justice Elubu
told Kwoyelo that he has a right to file an appeal against the conviction or sentencing
or against both within 14 days of the sentencing order.
//Cue in: “For all these…
Cue out:…or against both.
The court however excluded
issuing a death sentence on grounds that the convict had spent an exceedingly long
time in remand, and considered the broad transitional justice goal of the
aspect of reconciliation enunciated in the amnesty act.
It also excluded life
imprisonment on grounds that the sentence is reserved for offences of the most
extreme gravity or brutality with little or no possibility of reform which the
convict doesn’t fall in the category. Prosecutors and victims' counsel during a sentencing submission on October 14 had requested the court to jail Kwoyelo for life.
Justice Duncan Gaswaga noted that
the court considered the principle of totality which reflected on the aspect of
the offending behaviour, aggravating and mitigating factors relating to the
offences and those personal to the offender.
He said in the determination of
the aggravating factor, the court found evidence that the convict acted in a
command position for most of the offences playing an eminent role in the
planning, strategy and actual execution of extreme gravity.
“The commission of offences was
marked by extreme brutality, sadism, and cruelty employed. The vilest acts such
as the ones in Pagak were reserved for reprisal attacks. The victims have been
left with lasting physical and mental pains and sufferings,” said Justice
Gaswaga.
He also noted that in the mitigating
factor, the court considered that the convict is treated as the first offender
since he was conscripted and initiated into the LRA at a very tender age of 12
years and has since expressed remorse and willingness to reconcile with
victims.
According to Justice Gaswaga, the court also considered the convict was a mid-level commander not responsible for
the overall military command and strategy of the LRA adding that by the time
the offences were committed, the LRA was a very well-structured military system
with a hierarchy of command.
Kwoyelo’s defence lawyers however
say they will appeal the sentencing arguing that some of the sentences don’t reflect
the ends of justice.
Kwoyelo's lawyer Evans Ocheing, told Uganda Radio Network in an interview that they feel there
are flaws in the sentencing which need proper clarification.
//Cue in: “we have got…
Cue out:…they have made.”//
Robert Mackay, the victim's
defence lawyer welcomed the sentencing saying justice has been served for the
victims who have endured sufferings and yearned for reparations for a long
time.
//Cue in: “We are very…
Cue out:…In Northern Uganda.”//
The court has however opted to conduct
separate proceedings addressing the claims of reparations. Justice Elubu in his
ruling directed that the victim counsel make a formal application in which the
attorney general will be joined as a party. The victim's counsel is expected to
serve an application by November 8 on the prosecution, the attorney general and
the defence counsel who shall file their replies by November 22.
Kwoyelo is the first mid-level
LRA commander to be convicted by a domestic court in relation to the over two decades
bloody campaign in Northern Uganda.