The judges note that since Besigye argues that there is no validly elected government, it implies that there are no legally constituted courts of law and therefore they can’t grant him the remedies he is seeking.
The Constitutional Court has determined Besigye's 2011 petition
A panel of five Constitutional court judges has
dismissed an application by four time presidential candidate Dr. Kiiza Besigye
asking court to nullify the offense of unlawful assembly in the penal code Act.
The panel comprising Justices Kenneth Kakuru, Cheborion Barishaki, Elizabeth
Musoke, Steven Musota and Geoffrey Kiryabwire delivered its verdict this
On July, 7th, 2011, Besigye through his lawyers
from A. F Mpanga petitioned the Constitutional court to scrap the offense of
unlawful assembly from the Penal Code Act on grounds that it was unconstitutional.
In his suit, Besigye noted that the offense contravenes article 21, 27, 29 and 43 of the Constitution of
Uganda, which guarantee equality and freedom from discrimination, right to
privacy of persons, home and other property, protection of freedom of
expression movement, assembly, association and human rights freedoms.
Besigye ran to court after he was picked up
various times and arraigned before Kasangati and Nabweru Magistrate’s court for
staging unlawful assemblies when he led the Walk to Work protests that were prompted
by high commodity prices.
He asked the Constitutional court to declare his
arrest and subsequent prosecution in various courts unconstitutional. However, the five member panels of
Constitutional court judges unanimously dismissed the application in their judgment
read by Constitutional Court Registrar, Dr. Agnes Nkonge this morning.
noted that they have looked at Besigye’s political background and found that he
has been in contempt of Supreme Court orders resulting from the Amama Mbabazi
Presidential Election Petition challenging the declaration of president, Yoweri
Museveni as winner of 2016 elections.
The Supreme Court
heard the merits of the petition and concluded that Museveni was validly
elected president. However, the constitutional court judges noted that Besigye
defied the orders and went ahead to swear in himself as the legitimate
President of Uganda, appointed a cabinet and national Assembly.
The judges note that since Besigye
argues that there is no validly elected government, it implies that there are
no legally constituted courts of law and therefore they can’t grant him the
remedies he is seeking. “I would therefore decline to grant him the
remedies he seeks in the petition, maybe he will have to seek audience before
his own court or before the “Judge’, who Swore him in as President’, reads the
majority Judgment written by Justice Kakuru.
However, the justices
note that the action by police to criminalize citizen’s rights of political
expression and association as set out in the petition is unconstitutional. The Judges noted that hadn’t they looked at the previous political conduct of Besigye;
they would have allowed his application.
Besigye’s lawyer, Sophie Nantamba Nyombi and
Hilary Ebila who represented the attorney general declined to comment on the judgment.
Nantamba said she would only comment after receiving a copy of the judgment.