Launching the book in Kampala, Phil Clark said a strong notion of distance justice is not only reflected in the geographical location of the court but also in the various ways it operates. He says the Work of the International Criminal Court is also crippling African creativity for dealing with African problems such as conflicts. He cites the failure of the Juba Peace process between the Lord’s Resistance Army and the government of Uganda as one case which could have ended the conflict peacefully.
The International Criminal Court-ICC has come under fresh criticism
for suffocating justice mechanisms and politics in Africa.
This time, The Hague based court is being criticized by an
Australian Scholar and Lecturer at the SOAS, University of London Phil Clark,
in a new book titled; Distant Justice: The Impact of the International Criminal
Court on African Politics.
Phil Clark wrote the book featuring interviews with 650 people
after 11 years of field works in areas hosting activities of the International
Criminal Court – ICC in Northern Uganda and the Democratic Republic of Congo.
On the case of Dominic Ongwen prosecution in The Hague, the author
of the book says while there are fundamental problems with the domestic
judicial system, there is very little to gain by prosecuting Ongwen in The
Hague, as Clark explains.
//Cue in: “While is Dominic Ongwen….
Cue out: “…. dealt with in The Hague”//
Launching the book in Kampala, Phil Clark said a strong notion of
distance justice is not only reflected in the geographical location of the
court but also in the various ways it operates. He says the Work of the International
Criminal Court is also crippling African creativity for dealing with African
problems such as conflicts. He cites the failure of the Juba Peace process
between the Lords’s Resistance Army and the government of Uganda as one case
which could have ended the conflict peacefully.
Clark says his findings indicate that the International criminal
court (ICC) has failed to appreciate critical political, cultural and economic
context under which international crimes are committed in Africa by failing to
involve African legal technical experts familiar with the cultural context of
//Cue in: “In terms of the profile….
Cue out: “….very long way away”//
Clark says until about six months ago, the Office of the
Prosecutor (OTP) had a protocol limiting its investigators to ten days at a
time in the field for security purposes, something which compromised the
quality of their investigations, evidence collection from the fields and
contradicts the notion of complementarity to domestic judicial institutions.
Clark argues in the book that complementarity necessitate partnership with
domestic institutions instead of projecting itself as impartial and superior
criminal justice institution detached from politically polluted environment.
//Cue in: “Complementarity talks about….
Cue Out: “…. suspicious of the domestic space”//
The book mentions other grey areas in the works of the International Criminal
Court including inert failure to cultivate mechanisms for navigating difficult
political atmosphere of the absence of state cooperation.
The others are undermining domestic judiciaries across Africa as
it did in Ituri region in the North Eastern Democratic Republic of Congo in the
case of Thomas Lubanga, Mathieu Gudilo and Germa in Katanga which the
International Criminal Court stole from under the noses of the Military Court
system in Bunia which was already investigating those cases with massive
It says the court is even failing to gather strong evidence in
situations of absolute state cooperation as it was in the acquittal of former
President of Ivory Coast Laurent Gbagbo and Jean Pierre Bemba in the Democratic
Republic of Congo and the Central African Republic, as Phil explains.
//Cue in: “The problem in the Bemba….
Cue out: “…. conduct systematic investigations”//
Retired Justice Elizabeth Ibanda Nahamya, an International
Criminal Law, Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law expert says the
findings are serious indictment on the International Criminal Court (ICC).
She says while the book should help the court to restructure the
way it functions in order to achieve its desired objective of ending impunity
around the World, domestic African government must put in place resources for
dealing with mass crimes under the jurisdiction of the International Criminal
Margaret Ajok, the Transitional Advisor of the Justice Law and
Order Sector (JLOS) says missteps of the International Criminal Court (ICC) should
not be used to shrink the spaces for International Criminal Justice Mechanisms.
She said it is clear on the ground that without Pressure from the International
Criminal Court, the Lord’s Resistance Army conflict would have been complicated
to deal with.